Exploring Stories Where The Good Guys Lose

Overlord Screenshot

Apart from the Dungeon Keeper and Overlord series, I struggle to think of any games where you play as the ‘bad guy.’ Not sure about you, but always playing as the shining paragon of virtue whose hobbies include funding orphanages and adopting puppies gets a little old. To me, it’s as cliché as a tolkien-esque fantasy world riddled with evil orcs and gold-loving dwarves.

So I was pleased to see Obsidian trying out a different approach with their new RPG, Tyranny. Instead of playing a hero who saves the world, it turns the traditional approach around by you playing as a bad guy in a world where the apocalypse already happened and evil won the war.

Matthew Singh, Lead Producer for Obsidian, said this:

“What if we flipped that on its head? In this game, what if the clash between good versus evil has already happened, and evil has actually won. In this game, the armies of the Overlord, Kyros, have already come through the land, conquering all, and not only were you on the side of evil, you’re actually one of their leaders.’

Another touch I appreciated is you’re not following the mind numbingly generic hero’s journey. None of the lowly farm hand being approached by a mentor, discovering he has royal blood, travelling through hell to fight evil blah blah blah. Instead, you play as one of the leaders of the bad guys, with an already established reputation and presence in the world.

“…you don’t start off as the average farm boy that’s picked up a rusty dagger for the first time.”

There’s no telling if the game will be any good at this point, but I thought the story concept was a refreshing change from the tired formula. It reminds me a little of Brandon Sanderson’s Mistborn series, where the story revolves around a group performing a heist in a world where the evil overlord already won the war.

It’s an interesting concept, more of this originality in stories please game developers.

Photo by Niranjan licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top